Thread:Juliominako/@comment-26577820-20150707025351/@comment-26577820-20150707204826

Sailor Cure Fan wrote: (sorry I took a while to reply)

So you do know about the series, which means you would know where I'm going with this.

Yeah, the kind of crossover I'm thinking for MG is that of Smash Bros: a mascot fighter game. I prefer to call it platform fighter. You'll probably feel uncomfortable with the idea since the thought of innocent females fighting to the death (not really) seems very out-of-character of them, but nontheless it's an idea I came up with and I'm sticking to it (after all there were already two magical girl crossover fighting games made: Magical Chaser, which revolves around Cute Witches fighting each other (more Doremi Characters appears in that one), and Magical Battle Arena which mostly contains MGs that fall under the warrior type (which has more Nanoha characters than others) ).

As for its name, I call it Magical Girl Batalla--Magical Girl Battle.

At first, it was gonna be Magical All-Stars Batte Hearts, but then decided to change it because in my opinion, "All-Star" is such an overused title inclusion for most crossovers, and so I gave it the new name you see above.

There are a total of 150 different MGs that I included in this game. I divided them by what eras they hail from because I think they're easier to identify that way. So...here's the list/roster of the MGs:

-Name/Hero Name (Series/Season of Origins)

Classic MGs

-Usagi Tsukino/Sailor Moon, Ami Mizuno/Sailor Mercury, Rei Hino/Sailor Mars, Makoto Kino/Sailor Jupiter, and Minako Aino/Sailor Veuns (Sailor Moon)

-Chibiusa Tsukino/Sailor Chibi Moon, And Black Lady (Sailor Moon R)

-Haruka Tenoh/Sailor Uranus, Michiru Kaioh/Sailor Neptune, Setsuna Meioh and Hotaru Tomoe/Sailor Saturn (Sailor Moon S)

-CereCere/ Sailor Ceres, PallaPalla/ Sailor Pallas, JunJun/Sailor Juno, and VesVes/Sailor Vesta (Sailor Moon SuperS)

-Chibi-Chibi, Sailor Cosmos, Seiya Kou, Taiki Kou, and Yaten Kou/ Sailor Starlights, and Princess Kakyuu/ Sailor Kakyuu (Sailor Moon Stars)

-Sakura Kinomoto/Master of the Clow (Cardcaptor Sakura)

-Doremi Harukaze/Pink Ojamajo, Hazuki Fujiwara/Orange Ojamajo, Aiko Seno/Blue Ojamajo, Onpu Segawa/Purple Ojamajo, Momoko Asuka/ Yellow Ojamajo, Hanna-Chan/White  Ojamajo and Pop Harukaze/Red Ojamajo  (Ojamajo Doremi)

-Momoko Hanasaki/Wedding Peach, Yuri Tanima/ Angel Lily, Hinagiku Tamano/Angel Daisy, and  Scararlett O'Hara/Angel Salvia (Wedding Peach)

-Meimi Haneoka/Saint Tail (Saint Tail)

-Maron Kusakabe/Kaitou Jeanne (Kamikaze Kaitou Jeanne)

-Ririka Moriya/Nurse Angel (Nurse Angel Ririka SOS)

-Yui Kasuga/Corrector Yui, Haruna, Kisaragi/Corrector Haruna and Ai Shinzaki/ Corrector Ai (Corrector Yui)

-Utena Tenjou and Anthy Himemiya/Champions of the Rose Bride (Revolutionary Girl Utena)

-Hikaru Shidou/Magic Knight of Fire, Umi Ryuuzaki/Magic Knight of Water, and Fuu Hououji/ Magic Knight of  Wind (Magic Knights Rayearth)

-Minky Momo/Magical Princess (Magical Princess Minky Momo)

-Honey Kisaragi/Cutie Honey and Seira Hazuki/Misty Honey (Cutie Honey) -Sasami Kawai/Pretty Sammy (Pretty Sammy/Magical Project S)

Modern MGs (Note:Pretty Cure Seasons 13 & 14 are not aired yet)

-Sailor Luna (Sailor Moon Live Action)

-Nagisa Misumi/Cure Black and Honoka Yukishiro/Cure White (Futari wa Pretty Cure)

-Hikari Kujo/Shiny Luminous ( F utari  wa Pretty Cure Max Heart)

-Saki Hyuuga/ Cure Bloom and Mai Misho/Cure Egret  ( F utari  wa Pretty Cure Splash Star)

-Nozomi Yumehara/Cure Dream, Rin Natsuki/Cure Rouge, Urara Kasugano/Cure Lemonade, Komachi Akimoto/Cure Mint, and Karen Minazuki/Cure Aqua (Yes! Pretty Cure 5)

-Kurumi Mimino/Milky Rose (Yes! Prett Cure 5 GoGo!)

-Love Mpmozono/Cure Peach, Miki Aono/Cure Berry, Inori Yamabuki/ Cure Pine, and Setsuna Higashi/Cure Passion (Fresh Pretty Cure!)

-Tsubomi Hanaski/ Cure Blossom, Erika Kurumi/Cure Marine, Itsuki Myoudouin/ Cure Sunshine, and Yuri Tsukikage Cure Moonlight (HeartCatch Pretty Cure!)

-Hibiki Hojo/Cure Melody, Kanade Minamino/ Cure Rhythm Ellen Kurokawa/ Cure Beat, and Ako Shirabe/Cure Muse (Suite Pretty Cure♪)

-Miyuki Hoshizora/ Cure Happy, Akane Hino/Cure Sunny, Yayoi Kise/ Cure Peace, Nao Midorikawa/Cure March Reika Aoki/Cure Beauty and Candy/Cure Candy (Smile Pretty Cure!)

-Mana Aida/Cure Heart, Makoto Kenzaki /Cure Sword, Rikka Hishikawa/Cure Diamond, Alice Yotsuba/Cure Rosetta, and Aguri Madoka/Cure Ace (DokiDoki! Pretty Cure)

-Megumi Aino/Cure Lovely, Hime Shirayuki/Cure Princess, Yuko Omori/Cure Honey, and Iona Hikawa /Cure Fortune (HappinessCharge Pretty Cure!)

-Haruka Haruno/Cure Flora, Minami Kaido/Cure Mermaid Kirara Amanogawa/Cure Twinkle, and Towa Akagi/Cure Scarlet (Go! Princess Pretty Cure)

-Ayumi Sakagami/Cure Echo (Pretty All Stars)

-Ichigo Momomiya/Mew Ichigo, Mint Aizawa/Mew Mint, Lettuce, Midorika/Mew Lettuce, Pudding Fong/Mew Pudding, Zakuro Fujiwara/Mew Zokuro, and Berry Shirayuki/Mew Berry (Tokyo Mew Mew)

-Lucia Nanami/Pink Pearl Voice, Hanon Hosho/Blue Pearl Voice, Rina Toin/Green Pearl Voice, Caren/Purple Pearl Voice, Noel/Indigo Pearl Voice, Coco/Yellow Pearl Voice, and Serira/Orange Pearl Voice (Mermaid Melody Pichi Pichi Pitch)

-Nanoha Takamachi/Master of Raising Heart and Fate Testarossa/ Master of Bardiche ( Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha)

-Hayate Yagami/Master of Schwertkreuz, Signum/Master of Laevatein, Vita/ Master of Graf Eisen and Shamal/Master of Klarwind ( Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha A's)

-Sararu Nakajima/Master ofMaster of Both Mach Caliber and Revover Knuckle, Teana Lanster/Master of Cross Mirage, Caro Ru Lushe/Dragon Summoner, and Reinforce II (Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS)

-Mai Tokiha/HiME (Mai-HiME)

-Arika Yumemiya/Blue Sky Sapphire (Mai-Otome)

-Ahiru/Princess Tutu (Princess Tutu)

-Blossom, Bubbles, and Buttercup (Demashita! Powerpuff Girls Z)

-Fine and Rein/Prominence Princess (Fushigiboshi no Futagohime)

-Amu Hinamori/Amulet Heart (Shugo Chara)

-Akari Sakura/Ruby's Partner (Jewelpet)

-Madoka Kaname/Madoka Magica, Homura Akemi/ Hormura Magica, Sayaka Miki/Sayaka Magica, Mami Tomoe/Mami Magica, and Kyoko Sakura/Kyoko Magica (Puella Magi Madoka Magica)

-Haruka Minazuki/Red Angel, Aoi Kannazuki/Blue Angel and Kurumi Hazuki/White Angel (<span style="color:rgb(34,34,34);font-family:arial,sans-serif;font-size:13px;line-height:16.1200008392334px;">Kaitō Tenshi Twin Angel)

-Akane Isshiki/Vivid Red, Aoi Futaba/Vivid Blue, Wakaba Saegusa/ Vivid Green, and Himawari Shinomiya/Vivid Yellow (Vividred Operation)

-Neptune/Purple Heart, Noire/Black Heart, Blanc/ White Heart, and Vert/Green Heart (Hyperdimesion Neptunia: The Animation)

-Hibiki Tachibana/Third Relic Gungnir, Tsubasa kazanari/ First Relic Ame no Habiri, Chris Yukine/Second Relic Ichii-Bal, Kirika Akasuki/Igalima and Shirabe Tskuyomi/Shull Shagana (Symphogear)

-Ryuko Matoi/Kamui Senketsu and Satsuki Kiryuin/Kamui Junketsu (Kill la Kill)

-Kurai/Sailor Dark Moon (N/A) (A fighter that is made up)

As you can see, there are 47 characters from the old days of MG and 100  from recent years, which makes an equal 147. The first thing you'll notice is that all of the MGs I chose are all main characters of their shows. The reason? It's because I felt that if I include MGs from the same series, it's gonna make the other existing MGs feel left out, not to mention it'd be considered rubbing a series' popularity into the fans' faces. It's like the Nostalgia Critic, an internet celeberty for reviewing movies, said in one of his movie reviews: give the audience what they need not what they want.

Okay, so here's where the problem comes in. There is this 5 MGs I wanted to add because I thought she would be considered a rarity in this game:

Stardust Witch Meruru

Pruru Puru Pururin

Misty May

Magical Mako

Custom Magical Girl

I was gonna include Them to be a rare example of a show within a show  (And Original) MG appearing as a full-blown playable characters, but if that's gonna happen, I'll have to replace her with one of the MGs on the roster. But here are the problems: one, I am not gonna remove any of the classic ones because if I do, the roster would have more modern than classic ones, and two, there are several magical girls that are considered foils to others. Example, Juna, from Arjuna, is a foil to mostly the technology-themed MGs if you consider just what kind of MG Juna is.

So that's my problem. So julio, what do you think? Should I remove a character so I can put Meru in there or just make her into an assist character? Because I also plan on putting assist MG in there.

And...sorry if this is all long and complex. It's just that if don't tell you what exactly is the problem with my crossover idea, you might not fully get it.